We praise literature, yet we say we read less and less of it. Is the canon a living conversation or a museum? Does popular culture shape us more than we admit? And what do we do with great books that hold views we find wrong? To explore these questions, we spoke with Sarah Skwire, who argues that we will never stop needing stories, and that the classics are worth the effort.
About the Guest
Sarah Skwire is a Senior Program Officer at Liberty Fund. Her academic work ranges from Shakespeare to zombies and the broken window fallacy, and she writes regularly for Econlog, AdamSmithWorks and the Reading Room. She holds a PhD in English from the University of Chicago. She is the co-author of Writing with a Thesis.
Interview
Simon Sarevski: Let’s start provocative: We praise literature, yet read so little. Why is that the case?
Sarah Skwire: That might depend on what you mean by literature. We’re in a moment of enormous literary consumption, particularly by women. It’s often contemporary popular fiction, rather than classic works of literature, but there’s a LOT of reading going on, by a lot of people, in a lot of formats. (I think reading on Kindle and listening to audiobooks absolutely count as reading, by the way.) So we read a lot.
If you’re asking why we talk a good game about reading canonical literary classics but don’t actually read them, that’s probably because reading literary classics requires the kind of focused attention that is increasingly rare. When I was a teenager, my Dad, who was an American literature professor, told me that if I was reading anything written before the 20th century, I had to commit to giving it at least 100 pages before I expected it to really grab my attention. That’s a lot to demand from a reader these days, when we’ve all been trained by one-minute Instagram stories. I read a lot of classic literature when I’m on airplanes. Something about the white noise and the soothing knowledge that no one can ask me for anything while I’m at 35,000 feet clears my head and leaves me space to think about Paradise Lost or Anthony Trollope.
I also think that a lot of us have important works of literature assigned to us in school, where we are told they are important and that we are wrong if we don’t like them, instead of being encouraged to really think about them and develop and support our own thoughts about them. It would be amazing to tell students, “We’re reading The Great Gatsby. And you don’t have to like the book. A lot of people do, but it might not speak to you. But love it or hate it, you’re going to learn to support your opinions about it with evidence from the text, and you’re going to try to understand and respect the author’s project.” Wouldn’t that be freeing?
If people aren’t reading classic works of literature because they don’t like the ones they’ve read in the past, I think they probably just haven’t found the ones that will speak to them yet. It helps, I think, to read with other people so you can talk about a big book as you read through it. I’ve just finished up a three-year reading group on Shakespeare’s complete plays, and am about to start a year-long one on Paradise Lost. Those are massive reading commitments to complicated works, with deep histories, and important things to say. They’re also—often—really hard. So having other people to think with as you go is really helpful.
Are Shakespeare, Dickens and Dostoevsky, or any other names from the usual reading list, still read because they have something meaningful to say to us today, or do we sometimes preserve their reputations simply because they belong to the established canon?
Sarah Skwire: I don’t like all the works of literature that have lasted the test of time, but lasting the test of time surely means that they contain thoughts and expressions that have merit. But also, just because a work is canonical doesn’t mean that it is beyond criticism or that it will remain canonical. See Mark Twain’s takedown of James Fenimore Cooper, for example.
Whenever people talk about the literary canon like it’s something organized by a top-down committee who sit around and say, “Ah yes, Frankenstein is of sufficient literary merit to be included in the canon, but we must not allow The Shining,” I’m a little perplexed. There’s no official group that declares a work “canonical.” That’s just a word that we use to talk about works that have lasted, that a lot of people think are important, that get taught in schools, and that have influenced other writers. Things move in and out of the canon all the time, and everyone has a different list of what’s in it to begin with. It’s a very Hayekian process! We should be excited by that rather than suspicious.
———Related: Scott Nelson on why Cicero still matters———
From Achilles to Harry Potter, we admire fictional heroes for their courage and willingness to stand up for what they believe in. Why do we seem less willing to embrace those same qualities in real life?
Sarah Skwire: Doing the right thing is hard. Doing the right thing consistently, when people oppose you, is much, much harder. We read about, we admire, and we need fictional heroes not because it’s likely that we will be offered the chance to be truly great, but because they can inspire us to be better than we are. I’m never going to defeat Voldemort or (I hope) need to avenge the death of a loved one, but I can wake up every morning and try to do the next right thing that I have the chance to do. I think fictional heroes can help us do that. But I don’t think it ever stops being hard.
—Related: Larry Reed on what it takes to be a hero—
I tend to think of our views of the world as products of our reasoning. Yet fiction introduces us to people and ways of life we might never encounter in reality. How much of our worldview is shaped, perhaps without us realising it, by the fictional characters and stories we encounter?
Sarah Skwire: I guess I’ve never thought of our worldviews as being primarily the products of reasoning. I think of them as primarily arising from our culture, our experiences, our family backgrounds, our educations, our hobbies and interests, and a whole bunch of other inputs, to which we may or may not apply reasoning later on. So I’m probably the wrong person to answer this question. I certainly can’t give you an equation!
Why do we often dismiss popular culture as mere entertainment, yet sometimes treat it as enormously important when it comes to shaping our moral and political views?
Sarah Skwire: Well, when people dismiss popular culture as mere entertainment, they’re just wrong. They’re often wrong because they’re dismissive of young people, or women, or punk rock crowds, or sports fans, or whatever group it is that’s consuming the particular slice of popular culture they’re dismissing. So they want to claim it’s junk, and then panic that the junk is infecting the “real” culture that they’re trying to protect. It would make a lot more sense to take popular culture seriously all the way down. I’ve written a lot about how the popular fiction that we read for fun — mysteries, horror, romance fiction, and so on — tells us a lot about who we are and what we want. People who are interested in the moral and political views of the culture they’re living in should spend time with the art, music, and literature consumed by that culture. And that’s not usually going to be Proust. But it’s easier to make fun of pop culture than it is to take it seriously.
—Related: Bosko Karadjov on freedom, comics and pop culture—
With streaming platforms, video games and social media competing for our attention, does literature risk becoming a marginal part of popular culture? Or are we simply changing the way we consume stories?
Sarah Skwire: I think it’s the second. Jon Gottschall calls us the Storytelling Animal. We’re never going to stop being that. The methods of delivery might change, but we’re never going to stop needing to hear and tell stories.
From Tennyson’s The Charge of the Light Brigade to Wilfred Owen’s Dulce et Decorum Est, literature has shaped how generations remember war. What can literature capture about the human experience of conflict that journalism and historical accounts often cannot?
Sarah Skwire: Unlike the neutrality of good journalism and the even-handedness of well-researched history, literature allows for an intimate expression of a point of view. That opens a different kind of window into thinking about war.
We’re witnessing major conflicts in Ukraine and Gaza, yet we don’t seem to have contemporary writers or poets achieving the cultural recognition of those in the past. Has the role of the writer and literature changed, or is it simply too early to judge?
Sarah Skwire: I’m not sure if you’re asking why there hasn’t been poetry coming out of these conflicts or whether poets still can claim standing as “the unacknowledged legislators of mankind” as Shelley put it.
The first question is easy. There is writing coming out of these conflicts. Lots of it. It will take some time for the best of that writing to establish itself in the culture though. That’s, first of all, because the canon is a discovery process and a spontaneous order — see my answer to question two. It’s also because Ukraine and Gaza are ongoing. We don’t know the end of those stories yet. And a writer’s immediate reactions to an ongoing event aren’t always the ones that produce the great works that last centuries. Wordsworth says poetry is the “spontaneous overflow of emotion recollected in tranquility,” so I expect that we need time for writers to reflect and respond rather than reflexively react. That said, please take time to read “Your Body is the Only Commandment That Remains” by Shlomo Efrati, which I found incredibly effective and which was written in the days immediately following October 7th.
The second question is tougher. I do think art and artists of all kinds still possess great power to move us. But I also think that our culture moves so quickly now that it’s hard to keep up with events and with art created in response to those events. Also, because of new media, the barriers to getting work out there have lowered (which is great!), and that means there’s just so much more out there to read and see and hear. So I think, in many ways, art is still doing the same kind of work, but the world around that work has changed. We are overwhelmed.
Writers are celebrated for challenging conventional wisdom. Nevertheless, like everyone else, they are susceptible to intellectual fashions, writing what the cultural moment rewards rather than what it needs to hear. Have we gone too far with self-censorship in pursuit of profits?
Sarah Skwire: That’s a question that every writer has to answer in regards to his or her own work. Every writer needs to find the right balance between Dr. Johnson’s line that “No man but a blockhead ever wrote except for money” and Virginia Woolf’s that “Literature is strewn with the wreckage of men who have minded beyond reason the opinions of others.”
A widely shared meme says that 1984 was supposed to be a warning, not a manual. Yet we often seem more interested in invoking dystopian writers than taking their warnings seriously. Are we losing sight of what dystopian literature was meant to make us think about?
Sarah Skwire: Look, everyone likes to throw a little literary reference into their arguments to class up the joint. It doesn’t mean they’ve read the works they’re referencing, or that they’ve understood them if they’ve read them. But consider the American publisher who rejected Orwell’s Animal Farm because “the American public is not interested in animals.” There are always people who can read fiction, of any kind, and completely miss the message. This isn’t because we’re experiencing some hitherto unequalled cultural decline. It’s because a certain proportion of humans are just not very good at reading. We’ve also had a trend recently, for a lot of dystopian literature written for young adults. That may have made it easier for people who are inclined to think that young people aren’t that interesting or important to dismiss dystopian literature as trivial and for children. They’re wrong about all of that. They should be wondering, instead, why young people are so drawn to those works, and what that tells us about their worldviews, their fears, their hopes, and their concerns.
—Related: Matt Battaglia on art, freedom and propaganda—
What happens when a great work of literature expresses ideas or values we consider morally wrong? How do we square its artistic greatness with its moral shortcomings?
Sarah Skwire: I wish I knew which works of literature and which moral shortcomings you were thinking of, because this is a question where the details matter. Without any specifics, it’s hard to give you a good answer. But Milton gives us some solid thoughts on these questions in Areopagitica, where he points out that the moral goodness or badness of a book is nowhere near as important as the moral goodness or badness of the person reading the book. He says an evil-minded reader can read the most moral book and find evil in it, and a “discreet and judicious” reader can read the most evil book and find that it will “serve in many respects to discover, to confute, to forewarn, and to illustrate.”
Art and literature don’t just inject themselves into us. We interact with them. We don’t just passively appreciate them. We converse with them. Reading a book is as much about the reader as it is about the book. So when we read a work that has, say, attitudes towards race or gender or religion or sex or politics that we think are immoral, we wrestle with those attitudes. We can ask questions like “Why did this writer, who is so clearly brilliant in so many ways, think this horrible thing was true?” We can ask, “Is there anything in this writer’s own work that opens up space for a different viewpoint on this horrible thing?” We can ask, “If you take out the thing I object to, what is left of the work? Is the work just about being racist/sexist/classist/immoral, or is the author doing something else that is worthy of thinking about?”
We can also do the very important work of putting a piece of literature into its historical context. This doesn’t whitewash a work, nor does it absolve writers from having said horrible things, but it can help us understand why those ideas are in a work, and it helps us form a standard of comparison. The Merchant of Venice might contain some of the most antisemitic moments you’ve ever read… until you read The Jew of Malta or other Elizabethan representations of Jews.
I usually ask my guests to recommend a book or two to our readers. After everything we’ve discussed, I’m sure our readers would be delighted to hear your recommendations.
Sarah Skwire: The books that are open on my desk as I write these answers are, in no particular order: Milton’s Paradise Lost. The Mandibles by Lionel Shriver. The Warden by Anthony Trollope. Thinking Through Shakespeare by David Womersley. Louise Erdrich’s The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse. And I’m reading Charles De Lint’s Moonheart at night before I go to bed.
I’m much more interested in people finding books that speak to them and then shouting joyously about them so that the rest of us can try them out to see if they fit than I am in trying to make “one size fits all” reading recommendations of what everyone should read.
…but everyone should read Orwell’s essay “Politics and the English Language” at least once a year. It will make you a better reader and a better writer.
And finally, the question I ask all my guests: How do you find freedom in an unfree world?
Sarah Skwire: Live music. Sharing knowledge. Making things. Loving the people I love. And reading whatever I want.

